On Thanksgiving 2025 I posted a short list of permissions for anyone carrying grief to the holiday table. One of them read, “You are allowed to laugh and then sob and then laugh again, without apology.”

The apology is the part I keep coming back to. A friend tells a joke, a song comes on, a memory turns funny, and you laugh. A second later the guilt arrives, as if laughing meant you had loved them less.

What is penthos?

Penthos, an ancient Greek word, means grief, sorrow, sadness and mourning. In Homer it is most often the grief for someone who has crossed. At the end of the Iliad, Achilles and Priam, enemies, weep together until they have had their fill of weeping. Homer’s verb for that also means to take delight.

Centuries later, the Desert Fathers and Mothers of Egypt made penthos a spiritual practice: a mourning for their distance from God that was also a longing for Him. They found that the deepest weeping left them lighter. In the seventh century, at Sinai, John Climacus called it joy-making mourning. What they noticed about weeping is what I carry from them.

Who else has known this?

My own tradition keeps both in one verse: “A time to weep, and a time to laugh” (Ecclesiastes 3:4). When the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, wept for his infant son, Ibrahim, he called the tears mercy. At a jazz funeral in New Orleans, the band plays a dirge on the way to the grave, and on the way back the second line dances behind it.

Kahlil Gibran, a great influence on my work and philosophy, wrote this in 1923: “Your joy is your sorrow unmasked. And the selfsame well from which your laughter rises was oftentimes filled with your tears.”

So, is it okay to laugh?

I ask it as a father. My son Cameron crossed in 2008. He was thirteen. I think the laugh is very often the love. You laugh because you remember how they were, and how they were is still in you. If guilt follows, I have come to hear it as love checking that it is still there.

When joy surprises you

If joy surprises you this week, you might let it come. You might say their name, even silently, and tell them what you saw, the way you would have.

On Sunday 6 December 2026 I am leading a two-hour SUPERGRIEF retreat called PENTHOS: Joy-Bearing Grief. The title echoes Hannah Hunt’s study of penthos, Joy-bearing Grief. Nobody will be asked to be happy, and nobody will be asked to stay sad. If joy has not come back for you, you are welcome too. The door is here.

Rev. Rabbi Henry-Cameron Allen, OCP, ICGC
TheVirtualHermit.Quest

✦ ◆ ✦

Frequently Asked

Is it okay to laugh when you’re grieving?

Yes. Laughing while you grieve does not mean you loved them less. You laugh because you remember how they were, and how they were is still in you. The laugh is very often the love. If guilt follows a second later, it may be love checking that it is still there.

Why do I feel guilty for laughing after someone died?

Because part of you fears that joy means you have loved them less, or are leaving them behind. It does not. Traditions across the world have held grief and joy together for thousands of years. In Ecclesiastes there is “a time to weep, and a time to laugh,” and at a New Orleans jazz funeral the dirge on the way to the grave is followed by the second line dancing on the way back.

What is penthos?

Penthos is an ancient Greek word for grief, sorrow, sadness and mourning. In Homer it is most often the grief for someone who has crossed. The Desert Fathers and Mothers of Egypt made it a spiritual practice, a mourning for their distance from God that was also a longing for Him, and found that the deepest weeping left them lighter. In the seventh century John Climacus called it joy-making mourning.

What is joy-bearing grief?

Grief that carries joy inside it rather than shutting it out. Kahlil Gibran put it this way in 1923: “Your joy is your sorrow unmasked. And the selfsame well from which your laughter rises was oftentimes filled with your tears.”